1. Home
  2. Directory
  3. Indiana
  4. Newburgh
  5. Obstetrics Gynecology
  6. NPI Profile

DR. CAITLIN VAN SICKLER SCHULTHEIS M.D.
NPI 1871887067
Obstetrics & Gynecology in Newburgh, IN

Active since June 05, 2011PECOS EnrolledAccepts Medicare Assignment
74.71/100
CMS Quality Rating
4199 GATEWAY BLVD STE 2400, NEWBURGH, IN 47630(812) 471-0045(812) 471-0120 Get Directions Write a Review

NPPES record last updated: March 30, 2026. Verified against the NPPES registry weekly; last sync: August 09, 2026.

Record update history: Mar 30, 2026, Nov 30, 2017, Mar 22, 2017 and 2 more (5 updates tracked since 2017).

About Dr. Caitlin Van Sickler Schultheis M.d. NPPES

Official registry information on file with the National Plan and Provider Enumeration System.

DR. CAITLIN VAN SICKLER SCHULTHEIS M.D. (NPI 1871887067) is an individual obstetrics & gynecology provider in Newburgh, Indiana, licensed in Indiana (01074711A) and active in the NPI registry since June 2011. She is enrolled in Medicare PECOS, is affiliated with Deaconess Hospital Inc, and maintains a secondary practice location in Newburgh.

NPPES Registry Identity

NPI1871887067
Entity TypeIndividualFemale
Primary Taxonomy207V00000X
Provider Legal NameDR. CAITLIN VAN SICKLER SCHULTHEISCredential: M.D.
Location Address4199 GATEWAY BLVD STE 2400Newburgh, IN 47630-7972
Mailing Address4199 Gateway Blvd Ste 2400Newburgh, IN 47630-7972 · (812) 471-0045 · Fax (812) 471-0120
Phone(812) 471-0045
Fax(812) 471-0120
Sole ProprietorNo
Medical School CMSOtherGraduated 2007
Enumeration DateJune 5, 2011
Last NPPES UpdateMarch 30, 20265 updates tracked since enumeration
NPPES CertifiedMarch 30, 2026
✔ NPI 1871887067 is a valid, active identifier and passes the ISO check-digit test.

Specialties & Licenses

★ Primary SpecialtyObstetrics & GynecologyAllopathic & Osteopathic Physicians
Taxonomy Code207V00000X
Licenses✔ Licensed in IN · 01074711A✔ Licensed in FL · TRN 15959
Definition
An obstetrician/gynecologist possesses special knowledge, skills and professional capability in the medical and surgical care of the female reproductive system and associated disorders. This physician serves as a consultant to other physicians and as a primary physician for women.
4199 GATEWAY BLVD STE 2400, Newburgh, IN 47630
Open in Google Maps ↗

Secondary Practice Location 1

Location 14199 Gateway Blvd, Suite 2500Newburgh, IN 47630-8940 · Phone (812) 471-0045 · Fax (812) 471-0120

Other Identifiers 1

Medicaid201296680IN

Accepted Insurance

The full list of accepted plans is on the Insurance tab. Issuers include Ambetter from Buckeye Health Plan, Ambetter from Meridian, Ambetter Health and more.Insurance ›

Medicare Participation & PECOS CMS

Medicare enrollment, assignment, and ordering and referring status from the CMS PECOS system.

Medicare Enrollment Status

✔

Enrolled in Medicare and accepts Medicare assignment

Dr. Caitlin Van Sickler Schultheis M.d. is registered in PECOS and agrees to accept the Medicare-approved amount as full payment. Medicare patients are not billed beyond the standard deductible and coinsurance.

PECOS PAC ID3476789629
PECOS Enrollment IDI20150615002274
Eligible to Order & Refer✔ Part B Labs & Imaging✔ Durable Medical Equipment✔ Home Health Agency✔ Power Mobility DevicesPer the CMS Ordering and Referring file. Eligibility means Medicare pays claims that this provider orders or refers for these categories.

Areas of Expertise CMS Part B claims 2

Services this provider delivered to Medicare fee-for-service patients, from the CMS Medicare utilization data. Higher counts generally reflect more experience with a service; care delivered outside Medicare is not included.

Annual depression screening, 5 to 15 minutes G0444
An annual depression screening is a short, routine evaluation to check for signs of depression. It involves answering a series of questions about your feelings, thoughts, and behaviors. The process takes about 15 minutes and helps detect depression early for better management.
47 services47 patients
Cervical or vaginal cancer screening; pelvic and clinical breast examination G0101
This procedure involves checking for health issues in the lower abdomen and chest area. It helps identify early signs of certain conditions, increasing the chance for successful treatment. It's a routine check-up that's important for maintaining good health.
33 services33 patients

Hospital Affiliations CMS Care Compare 2

Hospitals where this provider delivers care, identified from recent Medicare claims and place-of-service records.

Deaconess Hospital Inc

Acute Care Hospitals · Evansville, IN
2/5 CMS rating
OwnershipVoluntary non-profit - Private
CMS Certification Number150082
Location600 Mary StEvansville, IN 47710 · Vanderburgh County
Emergency services

Women's Hospital The

Acute Care Hospitals · Newburgh, IN
5/5 CMS rating
OwnershipProprietary
CMS Certification Number150149
Location4199 Gateway BlvdNewburgh, IN 47630 · Warrick County
Emergency services Birthing friendly

Physician Visit Costs CMS claims · ZIP area

Typical Medicare office-visit costs in the 47630 ZIP code area, from fee-for-service claims. These are area statistics, not this provider’s prices; actual charges vary by service and coverage.

New Patient
$122.49 typical visit price
range $53.07 – $161.76
Typical copayment $30.62 (range $13.26 – $40.44)
Most-billed visit code 99204
Established Patient
$66.48 typical visit price
range $16.93 – $132.22
Typical copayment $16.62 (range $4.23 – $33.05)
Most-billed visit code 99213
Amounts reflect what Medicare beneficiaries in this ZIP area are typically charged for office visits. Patients with other coverage should check their individual plans.

Medicare Quality Performance CMS QPP · MIPS

Performance in the CMS Quality Payment Program: the MIPS final score across four weighted categories, and the individual quality measures reported to Medicare.

74.71/100
MIPS Final ScoreMerit-based Incentive Payment System · CMS Quality Payment Program
Scored as part of a group practice
Quality94.23
Promoting Interoperability100
Improvement Activities40
Cost21.48

Other Providers at the Same Location NPPES 20

Providers registered at the same practice address, or within the immediate area, according to the NPPES registry.

AMY CAROL WALL FNP
Nurse Practitioner (Family)
4199 GATEWAY BLVD STE 2400
NEWBURGH, IN 47630
Warrick County (812) 858-4610
LINDSEY MARIE PEARISON FNP-C
Nurse Practitioner (Family)
4199 GATEWAY BLVD STE 2400
NEWBURGH, IN 47630
Warrick County (812) 858-4610
MRS. ASHLY WILLIAMS
Nurse Practitioner (Family)
4199 GATEWAY BLVD STE 2400
NEWBURGH, IN 47630
Warrick County (812) 858-4600
ERICA B SCHMITT
Nurse Practitioner
4199 GATEWAY BLVD STE 2400
NEWBURGH, IN 47630
Warrick County (812) 858-4600
SUSAN E. LEINENBACH MD
Obstetrics & Gynecology
4199 GATEWAY BLVD STE 2400
NEWBURGH, IN 47630
Warrick County (812) 471-0045
DR. CHARLES L WAKEFIELD D.O.
Obstetrics & Gynecology
4199 GATEWAY BLVD STE 2400
NEWBURGH, IN 47630
Warrick County (812) 858-4600
WOMEN'S HEALTH CARE, PC
Obstetrics & Gynecology
4199 GATEWAY BLVD STE 2400
NEWBURGH, IN 47630
Warrick County (812) 858-4610
DR. KARA WILSON GEOGHEGAN MD
Obstetrics & Gynecology
4199 GATEWAY BLVD STE 2400
NEWBURGH, IN 47630
Warrick County (812) 471-0045

Frequently Asked Questions NPPES & CMS

Common questions about this NPI record, answered from the official NPPES registry and CMS datasets shown on this page.

What is Caitlin Schultheis's NPI number?

The NPI number for Caitlin Schultheis is 1871887067. It was assigned to this individual provider in the NPPES registry on June 5, 2011.

Where is Caitlin Schultheis located?

Caitlin Schultheis practices at 4199 Gateway Blvd Ste 2400, Newburgh, IN 47630. The listed phone number is (812) 471-0045.

What is Caitlin Schultheis's specialty?

The primary specialty registered for this NPI is Obstetrics & Gynecology with taxonomy code 207V00000X.

Is Caitlin Schultheis enrolled in Medicare?

Yes. Caitlin Schultheis is registered in the Medicare PECOS system and accepts Medicare assignment, which means accepting the Medicare-approved amount as payment in full for covered services.

What insurance does Caitlin Schultheis accept?

Health plans from Ambetter Health, Ambetter from Buckeye Health Plan, Ambetter from Meridian, Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield and CareSource list Caitlin Schultheis as in-network in at least one marketplace plan. Coverage varies by plan and year; verify with the insurer or the provider before a visit.

Is Caitlin Schultheis affiliated with any hospitals?

According to CMS data, Caitlin Schultheis is affiliated with Deaconess Hospital Inc and Women's Hospital The.

When was this NPI record last updated?

The NPPES record for Caitlin Schultheis was last updated on March 30, 2026. NPI Profile syncs weekly with the NPPES registry data releases published by CMS. This NPI record was last updated 4 months ago. If this record has changed at CMS more recently, you can request an on-demand re-check against the live CMS registry, directly from this page.