DR. SARAH EVAN MATHIS DO
Prescription History 1639618341
Family Medicine in Amherst, NY
What does Dr. Mathis prescribe?
In 2024, Dr. Mathis wrote 341 Medicare prescriptions for 14 medications. The most prescribed was Atenolol, with 44 prescriptions.
Medicare Part D only. These are prescriptions filled by people with Medicare drug coverage in 2024, from the CMS data released in 2026, the most recent year available. CMS does not publish medications with fewer than 11 prescriptions, so this is not a full list of what Dr. Mathis prescribes.
Medications 14 medications
Prescriptions filled under Medicare Part D in 2024. Select a medication to see what it is used for and how it compares with other New York prescribers.
What it is used for
Atenolol is used with or without other medications to treat high blood pressure (hypertension).
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 44 prescriptions for Atenolol, about as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (42). Medicare paid $2.90 per fill, versus $7.92 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
Isosorbide mononitrate is used to prevent chest pain (angina) in patients with a certain heart condition (coronary artery disease).
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 44 prescriptions for Isosorbide Mononitrate Er, about 1.2 times as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (36). Medicare paid $3.48 per fill, versus $12.21 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
This medication is used to treat certain mental/mood disorders (such as depression, anxiety).
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 38 prescriptions for Escitalopram Oxalate, about 66% as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (58). Medicare paid $4.04 per fill, versus $10.03 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
Irbesartan is used to treat high blood pressure (hypertension) and to help protect the kidneys from damage due to diabetes.
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 30 prescriptions for Irbesartan, about 86% as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (35). Medicare paid $8.25 per fill, versus $26.33 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
Verapamil is used to treat high blood pressure.
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 30 prescriptions for Verapamil Er, about 1.5 times as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (20). Medicare paid $6.06 per fill, versus $27.53 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
This medication is used to treat depression.
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 25 prescriptions for Bupropion Xl, about 62% as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (40). Medicare paid $8.21 per fill, versus $23.06 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
This medication is a beta-blocker used to treat chest pain (angina), heart failure, and high blood pressure.
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 25 prescriptions for Metoprolol Succinate, about 20% as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (126). Medicare paid $4.63 per fill, versus $14.99 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
Clopidogrel is used to prevent heart attacks and strokes in persons with heart disease (recent heart attack), recent stroke, or blood circulation disease (peripheral vascular disease).
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 23 prescriptions for Clopidogrel, about 41% as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (56). Medicare paid $4.16 per fill, versus $10.34 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
Rosuvastatin is used along with a proper diet to help lower "bad" cholesterol and fats (such as LDL, triglycerides) and raise "good" cholesterol (HDL) in the blood.
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 16 prescriptions for Rosuvastatin Calcium, about 13% as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (124). Medicare paid $6.59 per fill, versus $14.37 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
Apixaban is used to prevent serious blood clots from forming due to a certain irregular heartbeat (atrial fibrillation) or after hip/knee replacement surgery.
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 15 prescriptions for Eliquis, about 17% as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (86). Medicare paid $253.57 per fill, versus $874.81 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
Metformin is used with a proper diet and exercise program and possibly with other medications to control high blood sugar.
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 15 prescriptions for Metformin Hcl, about 15% as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (98). Medicare paid $7.76 per fill, versus $10.10 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
Alendronate is used to prevent and treat certain types of bone loss (osteoporosis) in adults.
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 13 prescriptions for Alendronate Sodium, about 25% as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (52). Medicare paid $4.77 per fill, versus $7.76 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
Atorvastatin is used along with a proper diet to help lower "bad" cholesterol and fats (such as LDL, triglycerides) and raise "good" cholesterol (HDL) in the blood.
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 12 prescriptions for Atorvastatin Calcium, about 6% as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (195). Medicare paid $16.30 per fill, versus $10.41 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
What it is used for
Latanoprost is used to treat high pressure inside the eye due to glaucoma (open angle type) or other eye diseases (such as ocular hypertension).
Compared with New York prescribers
Dr. Mathis wrote 11 prescriptions for Latanoprost, about 7% as often as the typical New York prescriber of it (159). Medicare paid $16.17 per fill, versus $11.29 statewide.
Volume reflects how many Medicare patients a practice sees as well as prescribing habits. It is not a measure of quality.
Questions about Dr. Mathis’s prescriptions
What does Dr. Mathis prescribe most?
In 2024 Medicare Part D data, Dr. Mathis's most prescribed medications were Atenolol (44), Isosorbide Mononitrate Er (44) and Escitalopram Oxalate (38).
How does Dr. Mathis's prescribing compare with other New York prescribers?
Of the 14 medications with a state comparison, Dr. Mathis prescribes 1 more often than the typical New York prescriber, 3 about as often and 10 less often. Volume reflects practice size as well as prescribing habits.
Does this list show every medication Dr. Mathis prescribes?
No. It covers prescriptions filled by people with Medicare Part D drug coverage in 2024, and CMS leaves out any medication with fewer than 11 prescriptions.
About this data
This page shows one provider’s slice of public Medicare files. NPI Profile does not receive prescriptions or patient records.
| Source | What it provides here | Data year |
|---|---|---|
| CMS Medicare Part D Prescribers by Provider and Drug | Each medication, prescriptions, patients, 30-day fills, days of medication and cost. State comparisons average the New York prescribers of the same medication and form, where at least five wrote it. | 2024 (released 2026, the most recent available) |
| CMS Medicare Part D Drug Spending Dashboard | What each medication is used for. | 2024 |
- Only prescriptions filled by people with Medicare Part D drug coverage are counted. Private insurance, Medicaid and cash purchases are not.
- CMS leaves out medications with fewer than 11 prescriptions and hides patient counts under 11.
- Cost per fill is what the plan and the patient paid the pharmacy together, not what you pay at the counter.
- Medication descriptions are summaries from CMS. They are not medical advice; ask a health care professional about any medication.